Ollie vs Farmer’s Dog Price: Which Fresh Dog Food Is More Affordable?

Fresh dog food has become one of the biggest trends in pet nutrition over the past few years. Instead of feeding heavily processed kibble, many dog owners are now switching to meals made with real meat, vegetables, and human-grade ingredients.

But there’s one question that comes up almost immediately when people consider switching:

How much does fresh dog food actually cost?

Two of the most popular fresh dog food delivery services today are Ollie and The Farmer’s Dog. Both companies promise high-quality meals made from real ingredients, customized for your dog and delivered straight to your door.

However, while the quality may be impressive, the price can be surprising if you’re used to buying regular kibble from a grocery store.

Fresh dog food subscriptions often cost several dollars per day, depending on your dog’s size and calorie needs. That’s why many pet owners specifically search for “Ollie vs Farmer’s Dog price” before deciding which service to try.

In this detailed guide, we’ll break down everything you need to know about the cost of Ollie dog food vs Farmer’s Dog, including:

• Daily cost comparisons
• Monthly price estimates
• How dog size affects pricing
• Which brand offers better value
• Ways to reduce fresh dog food costs

By the end of this article, you’ll have a clear understanding of which service is cheaper and which one might be worth the price for your dog.

Quick Price Comparison: Ollie vs Farmer’s Dog

Before diving into the details, it helps to see a quick overview of how the two services compare.

Looking at these estimates, it’s clear that The Farmer’s Dog usually costs slightly less per day than Ollie, especially for full fresh feeding plans.

That said, price can vary widely depending on factors like:

• Dog weight
• Activity level
• Daily calorie needs
• Meal plan type

Some dogs might cost only a couple of dollars per day to feed, while others — especially large breeds — may cost $10 or more per day.

3. How Fresh Dog Food Pricing Works

At first glance, fresh dog food subscriptions may seem expensive. However, there are several reasons why these meals cost more than traditional dry food.

Understanding how pricing works will make the Ollie vs Farmer’s Dog cost comparison easier to understand.

3.1 Why Fresh Dog Food Is More Expensive

Traditional kibble is highly processed and mass-produced, which keeps costs relatively low.

Fresh dog food, on the other hand, is prepared much more like human food.

Here are the main reasons why fresh meals cost more.

Human-Grade Ingredients

Both Ollie and The Farmer’s Dog use human-grade ingredients, meaning the food is prepared with ingredients that meet human food safety standards.

These ingredients typically include:

• Real meats such as chicken, beef, and turkey
• Fresh vegetables like carrots and spinach
• Healthy oils for skin and coat health

Higher-quality ingredients naturally increase production costs.

If you’re curious about what human-grade dog food actually means, this explanation from the AAFCO pet food guidelines provides a helpful overview.

Fresh Meat and Vegetables

Unlike kibble, which often contains meat meals or by-products, fresh dog food recipes use whole ingredients.

Meals often include visible ingredients such as:

• Shredded chicken
• Sweet potatoes
• Peas
• Carrots

Because these ingredients are less processed, they require careful preparation and handling.

Refrigerated Shipping

Another cost factor is cold-chain shipping.

Fresh dog food must remain cold during transportation, which requires:

• Insulated packaging
• Ice packs or dry ice
• Fast delivery times

These logistics add to the overall cost of the service.

Custom Meal Plans

Both Ollie and The Farmer’s Dog personalize meals for each dog.

When signing up, owners complete a questionnaire that asks about:

• Dog breed
• Age
• Weight
• Activity level
• Health conditions

Based on this information, the company calculates the exact number of calories your dog needs each day.

This personalization improves nutrition but also adds to production complexity.

3.2 Factors That Affect Price

Not every dog costs the same to feed with fresh food.

Several variables influence the final price.

Dog Weight

The biggest factor is dog size.

A small dog might eat only a few hundred calories per day, while a large breed may require more than 1,000 calories daily.

More calories = more food = higher cost.

Activity Level

Highly active dogs burn more calories than sedentary dogs.

Working dogs, athletic breeds, or dogs that exercise frequently may need larger portions, which increases the price.

Full Fresh vs Mixed Feeding

Ollie offers multiple feeding plans, including:

• Full fresh meal plans
• Mixed plans with baked food
• Partial fresh feeding

Mixed plans can significantly reduce the overall price.

Delivery Frequency

Some services allow customers to adjust delivery schedules.

Ordering larger shipments less frequently can sometimes reduce shipping costs.

Essential Clusters Dry Dog Food

The Honest Kitchen Human Grade Essential Clusters Dry Dog Food, Whole Grain Chicken 20 lb Bag

Amazon

3.3 Average Cost of Fresh Dog Food

Across the fresh dog food industry, the typical cost range is:

$2 to $10 per day depending on dog size and plan.

Here’s a general idea of what owners might expect.

Large dogs naturally cost more to feed because they require significantly more calories.

This is one reason some owners choose mixed feeding strategies, combining fresh food with kibble to reduce the overall cost.

4. Ollie Dog Food Price Breakdown

Now let’s look more closely at Ollie dog food price estimates.

While the exact price depends on your dog’s profile, most customers fall within a predictable cost range.

4.1 Ollie Price Per Day

Ollie fresh food plans typically start around $4 per day for smaller dogs.

For larger dogs, daily costs may increase significantly.

Typical daily ranges include:

Because Ollie offers several feeding plan options, prices can vary depending on whether you choose full fresh meals or a mixed plan.

4.2 Ollie Price Per Week

To better understand the cost, it helps to look at weekly estimates.

These prices assume full fresh feeding.

Choosing a mixed plan can reduce weekly costs.

4.3 Ollie Monthly Cost Estimates

For many dog owners, the monthly cost matters more than daily pricing.

Here are common estimates.

Some real-world case studies show Ollie costing around $300 per month for two small dogs, depending on calorie requirements.

4.4 Ollie Pricing Plans

One reason Ollie appeals to many dog owners is the flexibility of its pricing structure.

Full Fresh Plan

This plan provides 100% fresh meals delivered regularly.

Benefits include:

• Maximum nutrition
• High-quality ingredients
• Simplified feeding

However, this is also the most expensive option.

Mixed Plan

The mixed plan combines fresh food with baked food.

This allows owners to:

• Reduce costs
• Still include fresh meals in the diet

For many families, this plan offers a good balance between nutrition and affordability.

Half Fresh Plan

This plan is designed for owners who want to add fresh food as a topper or supplement rather than feeding it exclusively.

It’s the lowest-cost Ollie option, making it easier for owners to try fresh food without fully committing to the price.

Detailed Cost Breakdown & Real-World Pricing

Many dog owners researching fresh dog food subscription cost comparisons quickly notice something: the prices between brands can look similar at first, but the details tell a slightly different story.

Some services charge less per day but offer fewer options, while others provide more flexibility but come at a higher cost. Understanding how these numbers play out in real situations can make the decision much easier.

5. Farmer’s Dog Price Breakdown

The Farmer’s Dog is often described as one of the simplest fresh dog food services available. Unlike some competitors, it focuses exclusively on fresh, pre-portioned meals without offering baked or hybrid options.

That simplicity also influences how their pricing works.

Instead of multiple feeding tiers, the company calculates a custom plan for each dog based on calorie needs.

5.1 Farmer’s Dog Price Per Day

One reason The Farmer’s Dog attracts a lot of attention is its lower starting price.

For very small dogs, plans may start at roughly $2 per day, although this can vary depending on the dog’s age, weight, and activity level.

For most dogs, the typical daily cost falls somewhere within this range:

This places The Farmer’s Dog slightly below Ollie in many comparisons, particularly for full fresh feeding plans.

Because meals are already portioned for each dog, owners don’t need to measure servings or estimate feeding amounts.

5.2 Farmer’s Dog Weekly Cost

Looking at weekly pricing gives a clearer picture of what owners actually pay.

For many households, this means spending around $60 to $200 per month, depending on the dog’s size.

The reason large dogs cost more is straightforward: they simply eat more calories.

A 60-pound dog may require three or four times the amount of food needed for a small breed.

5.3 Farmer’s Dog Monthly Cost

Monthly estimates vary based on calorie requirements, but typical ranges look something like this.

Some customer examples show monthly costs around $180–$200 for smaller dogs, while large breeds can easily exceed $300 per month.

This is fairly typical across the fresh dog food industry, where feeding large dogs can quickly become expensive.

Still, compared with many competitors, The Farmer’s Dog tends to remain on the lower end of fresh food pricing.

6. Ollie vs Farmer’s Dog Price Comparison

Now that we’ve looked at both services individually, let’s place the numbers side by side.

This helps highlight where the biggest differences appear.

6.1 Cost Per Day Comparison

In most scenarios, The Farmer’s Dog ends up slightly cheaper per day, especially for small or medium dogs.

However, Ollie’s mixed feeding plans can change the equation.

Owners who combine fresh meals with baked food may bring the cost closer to Farmer’s Dog pricing.

6.2 Cost Per Month Comparison

While the ranges overlap, many real customer experiences show that Farmer’s Dog costs a bit less overall.

That said, the difference often comes down to $10–$40 per month, depending on the dog’s profile.

For some owners, that difference may not matter much if they prefer Ollie’s flexibility.

6.3 Cost Per Meal Comparison

Another helpful way to think about fresh dog food is cost per meal.

Let’s look at a simple example.

Although the numbers vary slightly, The Farmer’s Dog usually comes out a little cheaper per meal.

Still, the difference isn’t massive. Both services operate within a similar price range.

7. Price by Dog Size

When comparing Ollie vs Farmer’s Dog price, dog size plays a major role.

Let’s break down what owners might expect for different dog categories.

7.1 Cost for Small Dogs (Under 20 lbs)

Small dogs are the most affordable to feed with fresh food.

Typical daily costs include:

• Ollie: $4–$6 per day
• Farmer’s Dog: $2–$4 per day

Monthly costs usually range from $60 to $120.

Because smaller dogs eat less, many owners find fresh food subscriptions much more manageable financially.

7.2 Cost for Medium Dogs (20–50 lbs)

Medium-sized dogs sit in the middle of the pricing scale.

Typical costs include:

• Ollie: $6–$9 per day
• Farmer’s Dog: $4–$7 per day

Monthly costs often fall between $120 and $220.

At this size, the cost difference between brands becomes slightly more noticeable.

7.3 Cost for Large Dogs (50+ lbs)

Large dogs are where fresh food becomes significantly more expensive.

Typical daily costs include:

• Ollie: $9–$12 per day
• Farmer’s Dog: $7–$10 per day

Monthly costs may reach $250–$350 or more.

Because of this, many owners of large breeds choose partial fresh feeding, where fresh food is mixed with kibble.

This approach still improves nutrition while keeping the budget under control.

Savory Stews for Small Breeds Chicken & Salmon

Stella & Chewy’s Lil Bites Savory Stews for Small Breeds Chicken & Salmon Dinner in Broth, 2.7 oz. Cups (Pack of 12)

Amazon

8. Which Brand Is Cheaper?

When looking strictly at price, The Farmer’s Dog usually wins.

There are a few reasons for this.

Lower Starting Price

Farmer’s Dog plans can begin around $2 per day, which is lower than Ollie’s starting price.

Fully Fresh Meals Without Multiple Tiers

The Farmer’s Dog focuses on one type of product: fresh meals.

This simplicity may help keep the pricing structure more straightforward.

Slightly Lower Average Cost

Across many comparisons, the average daily price tends to be a bit lower than Ollie.

When Ollie Can Be Cheaper

Despite this, Ollie sometimes becomes more affordable if owners choose:

• Mixed feeding plans
• Partial fresh plans
• Baked food options

In those situations, Ollie’s flexibility may help reduce the total cost.

Value for Money, Ways to Save, and Final Verdict

By now, we’ve covered the numbers behind Ollie vs Farmer’s Dog price. We looked at daily costs, monthly estimates, and how dog size can dramatically change the amount you’ll pay for fresh food.

But price alone doesn’t tell the full story.

When people compare dog food subscriptions, they’re also asking a bigger question:

Is the cost actually worth it?

Fresh dog food often costs more than kibble, but many pet owners believe the quality, convenience, and potential health benefits justify the extra expense.

In this final section, we’ll look beyond raw price comparisons and explore value for money, ways to lower costs, discounts, and the final decision between Ollie and The Farmer’s Dog.

9. Value for Money Comparison

A food that costs slightly more isn’t always worse value. Sometimes the difference comes down to ingredients, convenience, or customization.

Both Ollie and The Farmer’s Dog position themselves as premium dog food services, so evaluating the value behind the price is important.

9.1 Ingredient Quality vs Price

One of the main reasons fresh dog food costs more is ingredient quality.

Both companies emphasize several things:

• Human-grade meats
• Fresh vegetables
• No artificial preservatives
• No fillers like corn gluten or meat by-products

Many recipes include ingredients you’d expect in home-cooked meals, such as:

• Chicken
• Beef
• Sweet potatoes
• Carrots
• Spinach

Because these foods are minimally processed, they retain more natural nutrients compared to traditional kibble.

9.2 Portion Control and Customization

Another value factor is feeding convenience.

The Farmer’s Dog focuses heavily on simplicity.

Every meal is:

• Pre-portioned
• Calorie-calculated
• Ready to serve

For busy dog owners, this removes the guesswork from feeding.

Ollie, on the other hand, offers more flexibility.

Owners can choose between:

• Full fresh plans
• Mixed plans
• Partial fresh feeding

This flexibility allows people to customize the diet based on budget, nutrition goals, or feeding preferences.

Some owners prefer Ollie because they can adjust plans as their dog’s needs change.

9.3 Cost vs Nutrition Value

When comparing Ollie vs Farmer’s Dog cost, many owners focus on how much they spend per month.

But another way to think about it is cost per nutritional quality.

Both brands provide:

• Complete and balanced meals
• Recipes formulated by veterinary nutritionists
• Carefully controlled ingredient sourcing

This means the food isn’t just “fresh” — it’s designed to meet established nutrition standards.

According to the AAFCO pet food nutrient guidelines, balanced dog foods must provide essential nutrients like amino acids, fatty acids, vitamins, and minerals.

Both companies meet these standards, which helps justify their premium pricing.

10. Ways to Reduce Fresh Dog Food Costs

For many households, the biggest barrier to fresh dog food is simply the price.

Fortunately, there are several ways to make it more affordable.

Mix Fresh Food With Kibble

One of the most common strategies is mixed feeding.

Instead of replacing kibble entirely, owners combine fresh food with traditional dog food.

Benefits include:

• Lower overall cost
• Improved flavor and nutrition
• Easier transition for picky eaters

Even adding a small amount of fresh food can improve meal quality.

Choose Partial Fresh Plans

Ollie allows customers to choose partial fresh feeding plans.

These plans deliver smaller quantities of fresh food that can be used as:

• Meal toppers
• Supplemental nutrition
• Occasional fresh meals

This approach significantly lowers the monthly cost.

Rotate Recipes Strategically

Another trick some owners use is rotating fresh meals rather than feeding them daily.

For example:

• Fresh meals 3–4 days per week
• Regular kibble the rest of the time

This reduces total food expenses while still introducing fresh ingredients.

Take Advantage of Introductory Offers

Many fresh dog food companies offer discounts to attract new customers.

Common promotions include:

• First box discounts
• Referral rewards
• Limited-time seasonal deals

These offers can reduce the first order by 30%–50%, which makes trying the service much easier.

11. Ollie vs Farmer’s Dog Discounts and Promotions

If you’re comparing Ollie dog food price vs Farmer’s Dog cost, it’s worth noting that both brands frequently run promotions.

Ollie Discounts

Ollie often offers promotions such as:

• First order discounts
• Referral credits
• Loyalty programs

New customers sometimes receive significant discounts on their first delivery.

Farmer’s Dog Discounts

The Farmer’s Dog also provides introductory offers.

These often include:

• Reduced pricing on the first shipment
• Free trial boxes
• Referral bonuses

Both companies rely heavily on subscriptions, so these promotions are designed to encourage new customers to try the service.

12. Hidden Costs to Consider

When calculating the cost of fresh dog food, there are a few extra factors worth thinking about.

These aren’t huge expenses, but they can influence the overall experience.

Freezer Storage

Fresh meals are delivered frozen, so you’ll need adequate freezer space.

Owners with multiple dogs sometimes need to store several weeks’ worth of meals at once.

Shipping Logistics

Both companies ship food in insulated boxes with ice packs.

While shipping is usually included in the price, delivery timing can require planning to ensure the food is stored quickly.

Larger Dogs Eat Much More

Fresh food becomes significantly more expensive for large breeds.

For example:

• A Chihuahua might cost $2 per day to feed
• A Labrador could cost $8–$10 per day

Because of this, large-dog owners are more likely to choose mixed feeding strategies.

Subscription Management

Both Ollie and The Farmer’s Dog operate through subscription models.

This means owners need to remember to:

• Adjust delivery schedules
• Pause shipments if needed
• Update plans when calorie needs change

Fortunately, both companies allow customers to modify their plans easily.

13. Pros and Cons of Each Brand (Price Perspective)

Looking strictly at cost, each brand has its own advantages.

Ollie Price Pros

Multiple pricing plans

Ollie allows customers to choose full fresh, mixed, or partial plans.

More flexibility

This flexibility helps reduce costs if owners don’t want to feed fresh meals exclusively.

Ollie Price Cons

Higher full-fresh cost

Feeding 100% fresh Ollie meals can be slightly more expensive than The Farmer’s Dog.

Farmer’s Dog Price Pros

Lower starting price

Farmer’s Dog often begins around $2 per day for smaller dogs.

Simple pricing structure

Because the company focuses only on fresh meals, pricing is straightforward.

Farmer’s Dog Price Cons

Less flexibility

There are fewer feeding plan variations compared to Ollie.

14. Ollie vs Farmer’s Dog Price Table (Detailed)

Here’s a complete price overview comparing both brands.

Overall, the price difference is noticeable but not dramatic.

Both services fall within a similar premium range.

15. Alternatives With Similar Pricing

If you’re exploring fresh dog food subscriptions, a few other brands offer comparable pricing.

Nom Nom

Nom Nom provides fresh meals prepared in small batches.

Prices are generally similar to The Farmer’s Dog.

JustFoodForDogs

This company offers both fresh meals and veterinary therapeutic diets.

Pricing tends to be slightly higher but includes specialized formulas.

Spot & Tango

Spot & Tango sells fresh meals and air-dried dog food, which can reduce cost while maintaining quality.

Freshpet

Freshpet is one of the few fresh dog food brands available in grocery stores.

It’s often cheaper than subscription services but less personalized.

16. Frequently Asked Questions

Is Ollie more expensive than Farmer’s Dog?

In many cases, yes. Ollie often costs slightly more for full fresh meal plans, although mixed plans can lower the price.

How much does Farmer’s Dog cost per month?

Most customers spend $60–$320 per month, depending on the dog’s size and calorie needs.

How much does Ollie cost per month?

Ollie plans usually range from $80 to $350 per month, depending on feeding style and dog size.

Is fresh dog food worth the cost?

For many owners, yes. Fresh diets often include higher-quality ingredients and fewer fillers compared to traditional kibble.

Which service is cheaper for large dogs?

The Farmer’s Dog typically costs slightly less, although the difference varies.

Can you mix fresh food with kibble?

Yes. Many owners combine fresh food with kibble to improve nutrition while reducing cost.

Do these services offer discounts?

Both companies frequently offer first-order discounts and referral promotions.

17. Final Verdict: Ollie vs Farmer’s Dog Price

When comparing Ollie vs Farmer’s Dog price, the difference isn’t huge — but it does exist.

Here’s the simple takeaway.

Choose Farmer’s Dog if you want

• A slightly cheaper fresh food option
• Simple pre-portioned meals
• Straightforward pricing

Choose Ollie if you want

• Flexible feeding plans
• More customization options
• Fresh and baked food combinations

For strictly budget-conscious dog owners, The Farmer’s Dog usually comes out ahead.

But for owners who value flexibility and feeding variety, Ollie may still be worth the extra cost.

At the end of the day, the best option depends on your dog’s needs, your feeding preferences, and your monthly pet budget.